Unfortunately, times have changed. Political outrage seems to be the new rule in the aftermath of a natural disaster. Rather than trusting the science and data, environmental opportunists have used the tragedy of February’s Winter Storm Uri, which plunged much of the American South into a treacherous deep freeze, as a weapon in their never-ending war against fossil fuels. They simply refuse to believe that during the storm electricity generated from wind and solar decreased 52% while the electricity generated from natural gas increased 72%.
Regardless of your thoughts on climate change, last month’s storm made painfully clear that climate catastrophists have an oversize influence on public policy. An obsessive focus on reaching the unattainable goal of zero carbon emissions led to decades of poor decisions that prioritized and subsidized unreliable energy sources (wind and solar) at the expense of reliable ones (natural gas, coal and nuclear). Texans now know that reliable energy is essential to our everyday lives.
The catastrophists’ oversize influence has produced a dangerous hypocrisy. Greens say that wind and solar can replace natural gas and coal to meet our energy needs while reducing carbon emissions. But when “renewables” fail, greens claim they aren’t to blame. “Wind power was expected to make up only a fraction of what the state planned for during the winter,” according to the Texas Tribune. Which is it?
NEWSLETTER SIGN-UP
Opinion: Morning Editorial Report
All the day's Opinion headlines.
PREVIEW
SUBSCRIBE
Ratepayers and taxpayers don’t have unlimited funds to invest in energy infrastructure. One choice always comes at the expense of another. The problem with wind and solar power is that investment in unreliable renewable sources has displaced investment in electricity generation from reliable energy sources. Worse, these investment decisions weren’t made voluntarily by individuals in the free market. They were forced on Texans by politicians in Washington.
According to the nonprofit Texas Public Policy Foundation, for every 39 cents the oil-and-gas industry received in federal taxpayer subsidies from 2010 to 2019, the wind industry received $18.86, 48 times as much, and the solar industry received $82.46, 211 times as much. By 2029 Texans will have spent $2.5 billion subsidizing wind and solar farms through local property-tax abatements and $14 billion building the Competitive Renewable Energy Zone’s transmission lines through their electricity bills. While most businesses must pay to bring their product to market, wind and solar get a free ride from Texas taxpayers.
If you add it all up, Texas taxpayers and ratepayers will shell out an estimated $36 billion by the end of the decade to subsidize wind and solar energy. These subsidies have tripled wind and solar capacity in the Lone Star State in the past 10 years, but as Texans learned first-hand during the storm, there is a huge difference between capacity and generation.
Instead of seeking solutions that increase reliable generation, several Democrats in Congress have suggested the answer lies in connecting Ercot, Texas’ independent electricity grid, with the rest of the nation. As someone who lives in East Texas, one of the few parts of the state not served by Ercot, I can tell you first-hand this wouldn’t have prevented the blackouts—we lost power too. “Having a grid that could have drawn more power from other states would have done little to ease the crisis,” Loren Steffy wrote in Texas Monthly. “With most of the country also facing bitterly cold temperatures, the rest of the U.S. wouldn’t have had much to spare anyway.”
Texas can’t afford to come within minutes of total system failure ever again, and the only way to ensure it never happens is to reverse policy choices that have tilted the state’s energy mix in favor of inefficient and unreliable sources. The mix needs to be rebalanced, with an emphasis on cheap, plentiful and reliable sources such as natural gas, coal and nuclear.
Mr. Christian, a Republican, is a commissioner of the Texas Railroad Commission, which regulates the state’s oil and gas industry.
WSJ Opinion: What Caused the Texas Blackouts?
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
UP NEXT
WSJ Opinion: What Caused the Texas Blackouts?
WSJ Opinion: What Caused the Texas Blackouts?
Climate advocates insist it wasn't the wind. Photo: ZUMA Press
Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8
Appeared in the March 20, 2021, print edition.
SHOW CONVERSATION
(215)
JOIN THE CONVERSATION
To Attract Black Employees, Companies Move to ThemBitter Alaska Meeting Complicates Already Shaky U.S.-China TiesHow Israel Delivered the World’s Fastest Vaccine RolloutA Proposed Bill of Rights for the Remote WorkerThe New Stimulus Act Offers Big Benefits for FamiliesNFTs: The Method to the Madness of a $69 Million Art SaleLas Vegas, After Its Latest Bust, Aims for Another BoomBillions of Cicadas Can’t Wait to Crash Your Outdoor PartyUsing Someone Else’s Netflix Password Is Likely to Get HarderWSJ News Exclusive | Visa Faces Antitrust Investigation Over Debit-Card Practices
WSJ MEMBER MESSAGE
Follow Your Portfolio
Follow Your Portfolio
Create a watch list that lets you track, manage and make decisions on the companies and indexes that matter to you.
CREATE NOW
SPONSORED OFFERS
TARGET:
Receive 20% discount on your order - Target promo code
MACY'S:
Macy's coupon - Sign up to get 25% off next order
SAKS FIFTH AVENUE:
20% off first order - Saks Fifth Avenue coupon
OLD NAVY:
Save 25% on Quilted Puffer Vest with Old Navy coupon
SHEIN:
25% off select purchase with SHEIN coupon
PRETTYLITTLETHING:
Sign up to newsletter for a 60% PrettyLittleThing coupon code
RECOMMENDED VIDEOS
[https://m.wsj.net/video/20210319/031821brazilicupatientssplash/031821brazilicupatientssplash_167x94.jpg]
Inside Brazil’s Fight Against P.1, a Fast-Spreading Covid-19 Variant
[https://m.wsj.net/video/20210318/glossarypfof031821/glossarypfof031821_167x94.jpg]
GameStop Saga Spurs Debate Over Payment for Order Flow Practice
[https://m.wsj.net/video/20210318/031821schoolreopening/031821schoolreopening_167x94.jpg]
How Risky Is the Classroom With Covid-19 Controls in Place?
[https://m.wsj.net/video/20210317/031921atlshoot8/031921atlshoot8_167x94.jpg]
Atlanta Shootings: Biden Condemns Violence Against Asian Americans
[https://m.wsj.net/video/20210315/boeingspace031521/boeingspace031521_167x94.jpg]
Why Boeing’s Starliner Test Launch Is Mission Critical
MOST POPULAR NEWS
Scientists Say They Found Cause of Rare Blood Clotting Linked to AstraZeneca Vaccine
Scientists Say They Found Cause of Rare Blood Clotting Linked to AstraZeneca Vaccine
What You Can and Can’t Do if You’ve Been Vaccinated: Travel, Risk Factors, What You Need to Know
What You Can and Can’t Do if You’ve Been Vaccinated: Travel, Risk Factors, What You Need to Know
Ron DeSantis: Don’t Trust the Elites
Ron DeSantis: Don’t Trust the Elites
Biden Meets Asian-American Leaders After Atlanta Spa Shootings
Biden Meets Asian-American Leaders After Atlanta Spa Shootings
China to Restrict Tesla Use by Military and State Employees
China to Restrict Tesla Use by Military and State Employees
MOST POPULAR OPINION
The Tax Cut Ban and the Constitution
Opinion: The Tax Cut Ban and the Constitution
A Day in a Scorched-Earth Senate
Opinion: A Day in a Scorched-Earth Senate
Andrew Cuomo Plots His Survival
Opinion: Andrew Cuomo Plots His Survival
The Securities and Politics Commission
Opinion: The Securities and Politics Commission
Congress Sowed the Seeds of Jan. 6 in 1887
Opinion: Congress Sowed the Seeds of Jan. 6 in 1887
BACK TO TOP
Edition
English
WSJ Membership Benefits
Customer Center
Legal Policies
Google Play
App Store
SIGN OUT
© 2021 Dow Jones & Company Inc.
All Rights Reserved.